2017 - Round 17 : Can MoSHBODS Regroup?
/The two RSMP forecasters took 1st and 2nd places on the Head-to-Head Tipster and Margin Predictor Leaderboards last weekend, in the latter case displacing MoSHBODS_Marg after an 8-week unbroken stint in the top position.
This week, the RSMP Head-to-Head Predictors have gone with the bookmaker favourites in all but the Gold Coast v Collingwood game where they've both preferred the narrow underdog Pies. Consult The Ladder, who shares 1st place with them, has opted for a full card of favourites. Actually, given Consult The Ladder's superior performance this season, maybe I should phrase that as BKB aligning itself with CTL.
Overall, the level of disagreement is low this week, at 18% about 2% points below the all-season average. Only the Suns v Pies game has more than two dissenting voices siding with the underdogs. The round's highest Disagreement Index belongs to Home Sweet Home, it and MoSSBODS_Marg and C_Marg the only Tipsters with an Index above the all-Tipster average for the round.
The Margin Predictors' average mean absolute deviation (MAD) of 4.0 points per Predictor per game is up a little on last week's 3.7 and is the highest it's been since Round 12. It's still a couple of tenths below the all-season average, however.
MoSHBODS_Marg's MAD is 4.5 points per game, which is also above the all-Predictor average, but, more importantly in the context of the overall competition lead, is considerably larger than both of the RSMP's MADs. MoSHBODS_Marg, who trails the RSMP Predictors by about 14 points, will do best if:
- Port Adelaide win by 52 points or more (16 point gain)
- Collingwood win by 10 points or more (7 point gain)
- St Kilda win by 14 points or more (6 point gain)
- West Coast win by 17 points or more (5 point gain)
- Adelaide win by 18 points or more (3 point gain)
From a game-by-game perspective, it's the Saints v Dons game that has the highest MAD (5.5 points per Predictor), ahead of the Tigers v Lions all-zoo affair (5.1 points per Predictor).
For the Head-to-Head Probability Predictors it's also the Saints v Dons game that has the highest MAD (7.2% points per Predictor), and the Tigers v Lions game that has the second-highest MAD (5.0% points per Predictor).
C_Prob has the round's highest MAD (8.4% points per game), ahead of MoSSBODS_Prob (4.8% points per game). MoSHBODS_Prob has probability estimates that are relatively similar to Bookie_OE and Bookie_RE and so is unlikely to move past them on the Leaderboard by round's end.
WAGERS
Investors face four head-to-head and four line bets this weekend, the octet amounting to 5.5% of the original Overall Portfolio, which is the largest single-round outlay by the two Funds since Round 11.
The upside, however, is broadly spread, with only Sydney (+1.1%) and St Kilda (+1%) able to bump up the value of the Overall Portfolio by 1% or more. Sydney (-1.2%) and St Kilda (-1.2%) also represent a large proportion of the downside, though they are joined by Port Adelaide (-1.3%) in this respect.
In total, about 5.5% of the Overall Portfolio is at risk, and a best-case set of results is capable of adding just under 4% to that Portfolio.
MoSSBODS AND MoSHBODS
Here are the MoS twins' views on team and total scoring for the week.
Commentary to follow.